Recall reasons are varied, which highlights the complexities of the supply chain. However, the most common appears to be accidental contamination.
Recorded recalls for 2012 in this category include: beer and pasta containing glass, chocolate and biscuits with metal, orange drink and tea cakes with plastic, ice cream with broken lolly sticks, insect-infected dates and chewy bars, rice pudding with rice weevils, frozen mince, chocolate, liquid egg whites and fruit and nuts with salmonella, chicken with listeria, olives with Clostridium botulinum, meat products with Listeria monocytogenes and juice with microbiological contamination.
Runner-up is incorrect labelling – namely, a failure to declare allergens such as: peanuts, soya, wheat, gluten, fish, shellfish, milk, nuts, peanuts, eggs, cheese, celery and sulphites. There are also cases of the wrong ‘use by’ or ‘best before’ dates being printed.
Unauthorised sources
Recalls this year were also for: undercooked mackerel, mouldy fruit cakes and Christmas puddings, cheese products containing non-approved dairy ingredients, root capsules with undeclared plant species, soups and spreads with ingredients from unauthorised sources, curry handled and packaged in an unapproved establishment.
The list also included: cottage pie with choking hazards, packaging containing the wrong product (a mix-up with gammon and haddock springs to mind), and drink bottles failing due to product fermentation.
I make no apologies for detailing these examples. They illustrate what happens when a partner within your supply chain fails. And, whether in or out of your control, the financial and reputational consequences for your business can be severe. They can also jeopardise your stakeholder relationships.
In today’s fast-moving social media environment, a product recall and the negative feedback associated with it can go ‘viral’ within minutes, reaching thousands, if not millions of people around the world. Leading ‘brands’ use social media platforms such as Facebook to boost their marketing and so can expect the same platforms to be conduits for bad news.
How you control the situation determines your future reputation. So it’s vital to have a public relations as well as disaster recovery strategy in place. In independent surveys, companies cite ‘loss of reputation’ as the greatest perceived risk facing their business.
Two-thirds of business leaders believe it’s harder to recover from reputational failure than it is to build and maintain a reputation. They say it takes, on average, three to four years for a company to recover from reputational damage. Some never recover. But if a ‘crisis’ is handled well, it may enhance your reputation.
Britvic spent £25M on a recall
In July, Britvic spent £25M on a recall of Fruit Shoot products and then, a month later, had to recall its Ballygowan water due to its odour. Commentators suggested the negative publicity associated with this recall would damage Britvic's brand.
To reduce the likelihood of a recall, review your company’s supply chain partners, assess their health and safety, risk management and business continuity plans and scrutinise their insurance cover. That will help to ensure you’re not left paying costs others may be liable for.
Similarly, audit your health and safety, risk management and business continuity plans. Also, satisfy yourself that the insurance you have in place is adequate for your liabilities – for example, product recall, contamination, lost business and public relation costs.
Insurance providers are here to ‘watch your back’ and protect your people, property, assets and reputation. They should audit your company and supply chain processes, identify and minimise the risks, review supply chain partnership relationships, create business continuity plans and ensure your insurance will cover costs following an unexpected crisis.
Those experienced in this sector will spot potential issues, help you manage a crisis and rebuild your brand, improving your chances of regaining your reputation and costs.
Richard Barker (Richard.barker@swib.co.uk) is a food and drink insurance specialist with Sutton Winson.
How to avoid recalls
- Review your company’s supply chain partners to assess their health and safety, risk management and business continuity plans and scrutinise their insurance cover.
- Audit your health and safety, risk management and business continuity plans.
- Ensure your insurance is adequate for your liabilities.
Source: Sutton Winson (www.suttonwinson.com)